Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
Service-Learning and Community Based Research
  • Presentation by Roxana Moayedi
  • Trinity College
2
Service-Learning and Social Change
  •    “Participation in an organized service activity that meets identified community needs and reflects on service activity as a means of gaining a deeper understanding of course content, a broader appreciation of the discipline, and an enhanced sense of civic responsibility”
  • From: A Service Learning Curriculum for Faculty.


3
Definitions
  • Volunteerism: Performing services for others in the community without material compensation, and the primary intended beneficiary is clearly the service recipient, (e.g. campus ministry activities).
  • Community Service: The engagement of students with the primary focus on the service being provided , as well as the benefits the service activities have on the recipients.  The students receive credit for learning about how their unpaid service work makes a difference in the lives of the service recipients, (e.g. high school requirement).
4
Definitions continued
  • Internship: Performing service primarily for the purpose of providing the students with pre-professional experience.  It allows students to prepare for and test out their career interests, while earning college credit.  However, development of students’ civic responsibility is not the primary focus.


5
Definitions continued
  • Service-Learning: Places equal emphasis on service and learning, as an educational requirement. Service-learning combines a course-based, credit-bearing, educational experience in which students (a) provide service (as defined by the community based organizations), and (b) reflect on the service activity as a means of gaining a better understanding of course content.  It is a pedagogy that allows students to test theories with real life experiences.  Students are assessed not for performing a public service, but rather for their reflective and analytical ability to apply the course material to their service experience.
6
Definitions Continued
  • Community Based Research:
  • CBR is the extension of service-learning.  In CBR projects, service primarily focuses on the provision of research and advocacy for community based organizations.
7
Community Based Organization
  • CBO refers to any nonprofit organization that empowers the marginalized and disadvantaged groups through, provision of direct service, research, advocacy, education, or outreach activities.
8
Service-Learning and CBR
  • Service-learning and CBR are the response to the following criticism of higher education:
  • Disconnection from local communities
  • Narrow definitions of academic research
  • Lack of students' civic engagement
9
Benefits of Service-Learning for Community Based Organizations
  • Through collaboration with CBO’s, universities can channel the following resources to serve the unmet needs in the community:
  • - Human labor
  • - Research and management skills
  • - Technical expertise
  • These resources will improve upon and expand the quality and quantity of  CBOs’ services.




  • b.  Enables Organizations to Build Capacity
      • Educate
      • Sharpen or develop new skills
      • Enhance confidence or efficacy
10
Benefits for Students:
  • To provide experiential learning opportunities
  • To enhance civic and social skills
  • To engage and learn about diversity
  • To allow for spiritual exploration of one's personal beliefs
  • To learn about systematic forms of inequalities and advocate for social justice
  • To develop social and professional networks


11
Benefits for Faculty:
  • Enhances student’s learning through active pedagogy
  • Reinvigorates new learning
  • Expands the traditional definition of academic research
  • Provides opportunities to combine teaching, research, and service
12
Benefits for Higher Education :
  • Educates committed and caring citizens
  • Improves faculty and staff morale
  • Builds relationships with the community
  • Fulfills the service mission of higher education institutions
  • Improves students’ retention, particularly of women and minorities
13
Principles of Good Practice
  • Provides structured opportunities for people to reflect critically on their service
  • Engages people in responsible and challenging actions for the common good.
  • Allows for those with needs to define those needs.
  • Matches service providers and service needs through a process that recognizes changing circumstances.
  • Expects a genuine, active, and sustained organizational commitment.
  • Includes training, supervision, monitoring, support, recognition, and evaluation to meet service and learning goals.
  • Insures that the time commitment for service and learning is flexible, appropriate, and in the best interest of all involved.
  • Is committed to program participation by and with diverse populations
  • Clarifies the responsibilities of each person and organization
  • Articulates clear service and learning goals for everyone involved
  • Honnet Porter, E. & Poulson  J. S.  Wingspread Principles of Good Practice in Combining Service Service and Learning. The Johnson Foundation. 1989.
14
Principles of Good Practice
  • - in Community Service-Learning Pedagogy


  • Academic credit is for learning, not for service.
  • Do not compromise academic rigor.
  • Set learning goals for students.
  • Establish criteria for the selection of community service placements.
  • Provide educationally sound mechanisms to harvest the community learning.
  • Provide supports for students to learn how to harvest community learning.
  • Minimize the distinction between the student’s community learning role and the classroom learning role.
  • Re-think the faculty instructional role.
  • Be prepared for uncertainty and variation in student learning outcomes.
  • Maximize the community responsibility orientation of the course.


  • Howard, J. ed. Praxis I:  A Faculty Casebook on Community Service Learning Arbor, MI: Office of Community Service Learning Press, University of Michigan.
15
Higher Education and CBOs:
Different Realities
  • Higher Education


  • Academic calendar
  • Academic reward system
  • Publish or perish


  • CBOs


  • Real deadlines
  • People’s livelihood
  • Impact on quality of life for
  • those most in need
16
Factors for Faculty Resistance
  • Requires too much work
  • Not rewarded by traditional academic rank and tenure system
  • Unpredictable experiential pedagogy
  • Political and professional risks
  • Expectations may exceed realistic “deliverables”


17
Institutional Sustainability Requires:
  • Creation of a permanent office/position(s) to build a bridge between academia and the community e.g. select community partners; maintain regular communication channels; define roles and responsibilities, etc.
  • Modification in faculty rank and tenure reward system e.g. redefining scholarship to include CBR and service-learning
  • Integration of service-learning and CBR into curriculum